Pantano's Eatery Menu

Welcome to Pantano's Eatery, a delightful sandwich shop in Plainview, NY, where culinary comfort meets exceptional service. Known for its vibrant menu, Pantano's features mouthwatering smashed burgers and enticing acai bowls. The acai bowls, available in one or two scoops, are adorned with fresh banana and strawberry, drizzled honey, granola, and coconut flakes—perfect for health enthusiasts.

For a more hearty experience, indulge in their gourmet sides like homemade mashed potatoes and mac and cheese, offering a perfect complement to any meal. The customer reviews echo the restaurant's charm, highlighting friendly staff and unforgettable flavors.

Whether you’re craving a “Nonna Rosa” sandwich, a delicious Cajun burger, or sweet potato fries, Pantano's satisfies every palate. With consistently fresh food and an inviting atmosphere, it’s a must-visit for anyone looking for a fulfilling meal in Long Island.

Kid's Menu

• Chicken Tender Junior

  Includes side french fries.

  US$10.99

• Hot Dog Junior

  US$7.99

• Junior House Salad

  Includes side french fries.

  US$9.99

• Mac & Cheese Junior

  Includes side french fries.

  US$10.99

• Grilled Cheese Junior

  Includes side french fries.

  US$10.99

Acai Bowls

• Acai Bowl ( 2 Scoops )

  Topped with Banana | Strawberry | Drizzle Honey | Granola | Coconut Flakes

  US$16.95

• Acai Bowl (1 Scoop)

  Topped with Banana | Strawberry | Drizzle Honey | Granola | Coconut Flakes

  US$9.99

Omelette Station

• Greek Omelette

  Farm fresh eggs with feta cheese, red onions and black olives.

  US$13.95

• Create Your Own Omelette

  Omelettes are prepared with three eggs and includes two complimentary fillings.

  US$12.95

• Spanish Omelette

  Farm fresh eggs with jalapeños, onions, diced ham and salsa.

  US$13.95

Breakfast

• Grilled Cheese Special

  Grilled American cheese with crispy bacon and tomato, served with French fries.

  US$13.95

• Ham Egg Cheese

  Ham Egg Cheese served on a Roll

  US$9.99

• Sausage Egg Cheese

  Sausage (Patty) Egg Cheese served on a Roll

  US$9.99

• Egg White Special

  Four fresh egg whites with feta cheese and tomatoes in a wrap.

  US$10.99

• Bacon Egg Cheese

  Bacon Egg Cheese served on a Roll

  US$9.99

• Sunrise Quesadilla

  Grilled steak with scrambled eggs and mozzarella cheese quesadilla style.

  US$13.95

• The Big Boy

  4 Eggs with bacon, sausage, ham and American cheese served on a hero.

  US$13.95

• 2 Eggs

  US$5.99

• Egg Cheese

  Egg Cheese served on a Roll

  US$8.99

• Classic BLT Sandwich

  Bacon, lettuce and tomato with mayonnaise.

  US$12.95

Build Your Deli Sandwich

• Salami

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Ham

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Pepper Turkey

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Turkey

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Prosciutto

  US$13.98

• Homemade Tuna Salad

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Roast Beef

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Pastrami

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Homemade Egg Salad

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Corned Beef

  US$12.98

• Grilled Chicken

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Homemade Chicken Salad

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Buffalo Crispy Chicken

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Honey Turkey

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Mortadella

  US$12.98

• Bologna

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

• Crispy Chicken Cutlet

  Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

  US$12.98

Breakfast Sides

• Homefries

  Side order of Homemade Homefries

  US$7.99

• Sausage Links

  US$7.95

• Hashbrowns (2 Pc)

  US$6.99

• Turkey Bacon (4 Pc)

  US$7.95

• Applewood Bacon (4 Pc)

  US$7.95

Signature Entrees

• Chicken Francese

  Fresh egg Battered breast of chicken sautéed in a classic white wine, lemon and butter sauce.

  US$12.99

• Eggplant Rollatini

  Fresh battered eggplant rolled with seasoned ricotta, baked parmigiana style with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, served over penne pasta.

  US$13.99

• Chicken Alla Matteo

  Fresh grilled chicken breast topped with fresh bruschetta. Served over rice.

  US$10.99

• Balsamic Chicken

  Fresh chicken breast marinated in balsamic vinegar and topped with a mit medley of sautéed fresh garden vegetables. Served over vegetable rice.

  US$12.99

P-licious Paninis

• The Anderson

  Mini crab cakes, Asian slaw, goat cheese with southwest mayonnaise. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$18.95

• The Larry

  Grilled cajun shrimp, avocado, applewood bacon, romaine and tomatoes with 1000 island dressing Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$18.95

• The Cathy

  Crispy chicken cutlet with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and 1000 island dressing. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Turnpike

  Grilled pastrami with swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mustard. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Peter

  Imported prosciutto with fresh mozzarella, baby arugula and sliced tomatoes with balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$18.95

• The Francisco

  Crispy chicken cutlet with breaded eggplant, mozzarella and vodka sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$18.95

• The Carlo

  Grilled chicken with onions, provolone cheese and pesto mayonnaise. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Gianluca (John Luca)

  Crispy chicken cutlet with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, bleu cheese. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Nonna Rosa

  Grilled chicken with roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$16.95

• The Griller

  Grilled Roast Beef with mozzarella cheese and brown gravy. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Marco

  Fried raviolis, sundried tomatoes, marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

Burgers

• The Cajun Burger

  Cajun cheeseburger with sautéed onions, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and side onion rings.

  US$16.99

• Chicken Burger Deluxe

  Homemade Chicken Burger topped with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Avocado Side Sweet Potato Fries

  US$14.99

• Classic Cheese Burger Deluxe

  6oz CheeseBurger with Lettuce, tomato served side Fries

  US$14.99

• The Philly Burger

  Cheeseburger topped with Philly steak, cheddar, onion rings two and side mashed potatoes.

  US$16.99

Gourmet Market Sides

• Homemade Mashed Potatoes (1/2 Lb)

  US$7.99

• Macaroni & Cheese

  US$8.99

• Homemade Creamed Spinach (1/2 Lb)

  US$4.99

• Fresh Steamed Vegetables (1/2 Lb)

  US$4.99

Signature Pastas

• Rigatoni Bolognese

  Fresh ground meat with garlic and pomodoro sauce.

  US$22.99

• Gnocchi (Full)

  Fresh potato pasta topped with sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil.

  US$11.99

• Spaghetti Calamari Marinara (Full)

  Fresh calamari sautéed in a traditional garlic and herb plum tomato sauce.

  US$14.99

• Penne Caprese

  Penne pasta topped with fresh homemade mozzarella cheese and sautéed in plum tomato and basil sauce.

  US$23.99

• Spaghetti Pomodoro

  Pantano's homemade tomato sauce served over spaghetti.

  US$9.99

• Vegetable Ravioli Primavera (Full)

  Cheese ravioli in a light primavera sauce mixed with fresh grilled vegetables.

  US$16.99

• Bow Tie Delite

  Bowtie pasta with grilled chicken, broccoli rabe with sundried tomato, all sautéed in garlic and oil.

  US$19.99

• Penne Alla Vodka

  Imported prosciutto sautéed in a creamy pink vodka sauce.

  US$19.99

• Rigatoni Fiorentina

  Fresh chicken medallions with spinach and mozzarella cheese, sautéed in a creamy pink sauce.

  US$22.99

• Penne Al Pesto

  Penne pasta with homemade pesto sauce.

  US$22.99

• Tortellini Alfredo

  Our classic light cream sauce topped with parmigiano reggiano.

  US$22.99

• Spaghetti Pomodoro With Italian Sausage

  Pantano's homemade tomato sauce served over spaghetti.

  US$12.99

• Spaghetti Pomodoro With Meatballs

  Pantano's homemade tomato sauce served over spaghetti.

  US$12.99

• Rigatoni Alla Siciliana

  Fresh battered eggplant, basil, garlic parmigiana and our traditional pomodoro sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella.

  US$19.99

Appetizers

• Mini Crab Cakes (6)

  Served with a side of Asian slaw and chipotle sauce.

  US$14.95

• Mozzarella Sticks (6)

  Served with a side of marinara sauce.

  US$11.99

• Homemade Soup (16 Oz)

  Made fresh daily.

  US$8.99

• Honey Bbq Wings (12)

  US$16.99

• Buffalo Wings (12)

  US$16.99

• Chicken Tenders (4)

  Served with a side of honey mustard.

  US$12.95

• Fried Ravioli

  Served with a side of marinara sauce.

  US$14.95

• Creamed Homemade Spinach Dip

  Served with a side of pita chips and homemade nacho chips.

  US$16.99

• Sampler

  Two pieces potato skins, four pieces mozzarella sticks and four pieces buffalo wings.

  US$14.99

• Garlic Mozzarella Bread

  Garlic bread with melted mozzarella cheese and a side of marinara sauce.

  US$9.99

• Chicken Wings (12)

  Plain, Buffalo,Honey BBQ.

  US$16.99

Bagels

• Bagel With Cream Cheese

  US$6.99

• Individual Bagel

  Plain, everything, sesame, poppy, cinnamon raisin, egg, garlic, pumpernickel, whole wheat, whole wheat everything.

  US$2.99

• Bagel With Veggie Cream Cheese

  US$6.99

• Bagel With Butter

  Plain Bagel with Butter ( While supplies are available )

  US$5.95

• Bagel With Olive Cream Cheese

  US$6.99

• Bagel With Bacon Cream Cheese

  US$8.99

Coffee & Tea

• Iced Coffee (24 Oz)

  Regular, Decaf, Decaf Hazelnut, Cappuccino, Caramel, Crumb Cake, French Vanilla, Toasted Marshmallow.

  US$4.99

• Homemade Sweet Lemonade

  US$5.49

• Tea

  US$1.98

• Homemade Sweet Iced Tea

  US$5.49

Signature Salads

• Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

  Served mixed with homemade Caesar dressing.

  US$20.95

• Pantano Salad

  Baby mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers and carrots topped with bbq grilled chicken.

  US$18.99

• Summer Salad

  Mixed greens, apples, goat cheese, shaved almonds, dried cranberries and chick peas. Chopped.

  US$20.95

• Sunrise Salad

  Crispy buffalo chicken strips served over romaine hearts with tomatoes and shredded cheddar cheese.

  US$20.95

• Spinach Delite

  Spinach leaves, tomatoes, bacon, crumbled egg and grilled chicken.

  US$20.95

• Classic Chef's Salad

  Tossed salad with turkey, ham, American cheese and boiled eggs.

  US$18.99

• Greek Salad

  Tossed salad, feta cheese, red onions and black olives.

  US$18.99

• Pesto Grilled Chicken Salad

  Served over a tossed salad and pesto marinara on the side.

  US$20.95

• BBQ Popcorn Shrimp

  Served over Caesar salad.

  US$23.95

• Diet Delite

  Tossed salad with honey turkey and alpine lace swiss.

  US$18.95

• Friedman Salad

  Tossed salad with grilled chicken, and dried cranberries. Chopped.

  US$20.95

• Warm Salad

  Baby mixed greens, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers with balsamic honey mustard chicken.

  US$20.95

• Alyssa Salad

  Mixed greens, tomatoes, olives, roasted peppers, gorgonzola and roasted pecans. Chopped.

  US$18.99

Smashed Meatballs

• Sloppy Italian

  Smashed Meatballs, prosciutto, burrata, pesto vodka sauce on toasted bun

  US$14.95

• Sloppy Drunk

  Smashed Meatballs, sautéed onions, pepperoni, mozzarella, vodka saut on toasted bun

  US$13.95

• Sloppy Mess

  Smashed Meatballs, French fries, Onion Rings, mozzarella, gravy on garlic Toasted Bun

  US$12.95

Wraps

• The Terrific Teriyaki

  Teriyaki chicken and rice. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Ruth's

  Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Megan

  Penne alla vodka with crispy chicken cutlet stuffed in a Wrap. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Broadway

  Balsamic grilled chicken, and fresh grilled vegetables Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Mezz

  Grilled chicken, feta cheese, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Gittleson

  Grilled chicken with homemade creamed spinach. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$16.59

• The Stoner

  Baked chicken cutlet parmigiana with side of marinara sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Rob

  Boneless buffalo crispy chicken with jalapeños, fresh mozzarella, lettuce and bleu cheese. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Gabby

  Crispy chicken, mac n cheese, bacon bits and mozzarella sticks. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

  Grilled chicken Caesar.

  US$17.95

• The Crazy Rich

  Crispy chicken cutlet with cheddar, bacon, ranch, and French fries (Inside). Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Big John

  Crispy chicken fingers, mozzarella, brown gravy and French fries (Inside). Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Tater

  Crispy Chicken, Spicy Tater Tots, Pepper Jack Cheese, Ranch. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Amigo

  Pesto grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, and tomato. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Nico

  Crispy chicken cutlet with peppers, onions, cheddar cheese and sour cream. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Mia

  Grilled chicken with avocado, gorgonzola, mixed greens and raspberry vinaigrette. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

• The Max

  Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella with a creamy vodka sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$17.95

Smashed Burgers

• Smashed Burger Box Deal

  4 x Single Smashed Burgers ( patty/American, pickles, secret sauce )

  US$19.99

• (2) Smashed Burgers With Side Fries

  (2) Smashed Burgers with American cheese, pickles, onions, house Russian dressing on a Potato Bun

  US$10.99

• (2) Double Smashed Burger With Side Fries

  (2) Double Smashed Burgers with American cheese, pickles, onions, house Russian dressing on a Potato Bun

  US$12.99

• Triple Smashed Burger

  3 Smashed Patties, American Cheese, pickles, secret sauce on a potato bun

  US$13.00

• Double Smashed Burger

  2 Smashed Patties, American cheese, pickles, Secret sauce on potato bun

  US$10.00

• Double Double Fatty Melt

  (2) Smashed Burger Patties with onions, American on an Upside down Potato Bun ( Grilled )

  US$10.99

• Jalapeno Smashed Double

  Double smashed Patties, Swiss cheese, caramelized onion, homemade chipotle sauce, jalapeños on a Potato Bun

  US$16.00

• Single Smashed Burger

  Smashed Patty, American cheese, pickles, Secret sauce

  US$7.00

• Filthy Fries

  French Fries topped with American Cheese, caramelized onions, Homemade Chipotle sauce, smashed patty

  US$11.50

Fries and Sides

• Seasoned Fries

  US$7.99

• Regular French Fries

  US$6.99

• Onion Rings

  Battered.

  US$7.99

• Disco Fries

  Regular fries with melted mozzarella and (Side) Brown gravy.

  US$10.99

• Sweet Potato Fries

  US$9.99

• Chili Cheese Fries

  Regular fries with American cheese and chili.

  US$11.99

• Willie Fries

  French fries topped with bacon bits and cheddar cheese.

  US$11.99

On the Griddle

• Belgiun Waffle

  Served with powdered sugar butter and syrup.

  US$9.99

• Panwich

  Two farm fresh eggs sandwiched between two mini buttermilk pancakes.

  US$4.99

• Breakfast Combo # 2

  Buttermilk Pancakes served with Eggwhites and Turkey-Bacon

  US$12.99

• Homemade Golden Brown French Toast (3 Pc)

  Homemade French Toast Served with powdered sugar Side Butter and Syrup.

  US$11.99

• Breakfast Combo # 1

  French Toast served with eggs, Bacon strips, Sausage Links

  US$12.99

• Heavenly French Toast

  With syrup pre-poured. French toast topped with warm strawberries, sliced bananas and chocolate chips.

  US$14.99

• Homemade Buttermilk Pancakes (3 Pc)

  Served with powdered sugar with Side Butter and Syrup.

  US$11.99

• Banana Stack

  (3) Buttermilk pancakes topped with fresh bananas, pecans and caramel.

  US$13.99

• Western Omelette Platter

  (4) Eggs with diced ham, onions and peppers. Platter choice served with homefries and white toast.

  US$14.99

• Ultimate Stack

  Buttermilk pancakes two pieces served with bacon, 3 eggs and American cheese.

  US$12.99

• Western Sandwich

  Three eggs with diced ham, onions and peppers.

  US$9.99

Hot Stuff

• Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

  Fried Eggplant w/ mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce.

  US$17.95

• Meatball Parmigiana Hero

  Meatballs w/ mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce.

  US$17.95

• Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero

  Chicken Cutlet w/ mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce.

  US$18.95

• Chicken Quesadilla

  With peppers, onions, sour cream and cheddar cheese. Served with a side of French fries.

  US$19.99

• Beef Quesadilla

  With peppers, onions, sour cream and cheddar cheese. Served with a side of rice or regular fries.

  US$16.99

• Chicken Vodka Parm

  Chicken cutlet w/ mozzarella cheese, vodka sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

  US$18.95

• Philly Cheese Steak Hero

  Sliced Philly steak with peppers, onions, cheddar cheese and mayo.

  US$17.95

Baked Goods

• Rainbow Cookies

  US$6.99

• Crumbcake

  US$3.99

• Yogurt Muffins

  Choose from: Corn, Blueberry, Banana Nut, Banana Chip, Cappuccino, Cinnamuffin, Chocolate or Vanilla Chip and more.

  US$4.99

• Brownie

  US$4.95

• Fresh Baked Cookies

  Fresh Baked Daily

  US$3.99

Baked Pastas

• Baked Ziti

  With seasoned ricotta cheese, pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.

  US$21.99

• Vegetable Baked Lasagna (Full)

  Traditional classic lasagna with seasoned ricotta cheese, melted mozzarella and pomodoro sauce.

  US$10.99

• Baked Ravioli (Full)

  Filled with seasoned ricotta cheese, topped with pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.

  US$10.99

• Meat Baked Lasagna (Full)

  Traditional classic lasagna with seasoned ricotta cheese, melted mozzarella and pomodoro sauce.

  US$10.99

• Baked Manicotti (Full)

  Fresh pasta stuffed with seasoned ricotta cheese, topped with pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.

  US$10.99

• Baked Stuffed Shells (Full)

  Jumbo pasta shells stuffed with seasoned ricotta cheese, topped with fresh pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.

  US$10.99

Signature Specialties

• The Classic American

  Roast beef, turkey, ham, American, swiss, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.

  US$17.95

• The Il Bacio

  Grilled marinated chicken with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.

  US$8.99

• The Duke's Dip

  Thinly sliced beef or grilled chicken covered with mozzarella cheese garlic mayonnaise on a brick oven hero. Served with au jus sauce and creamy mashed potatoes on the side.

  US$19.95

• The Phil Special

  Grilled roast beef on garlic bread with mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, and Italian dressing.

  US$13.99

• The Burnside

  Crispy chicken cutlet with melted mozzarella and honey mustard.

  US$17.95

• The Rueben Classic

  Grilled pastrami, swiss cheese, coleslaw, russian dressing on toasted rye.

  US$12.99

• The Italiano

  Crispy chicken cutlet on garlic bread with grilled ham cappy and mozzarella.

  US$13.99

• The Jenny

  Crispy chicken cutlet with melted American, lettuce and mayonnaise.

  US$17.95

• The Delivery Boy Special

  Balsamic grilled chicken, melted swiss, lettuce and tomato.

  US$8.49

• The Guido

  Crispy chicken cutlet with melted American, bacon and 1000 island dressing.

  US$16.99

• The Michelangelo

  Grilled corned beef with melted swiss, sauerkraut and mustard.

  US$17.95

• The Pesci

  Grilled roast beef with melted American, onion and 1000 island dressing.

  US$17.95

• The Pantano Special

  Genoa salami, mortadella, ham cappy, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato with Italian dressing.

  US$17.95